Alright. It's that time again. It took me a little longer to get back around to the sheepskin rundown than I thought it would. It turns out that some of you took my advice, and the UGG rush has hit earlier than ever. Thanks to all of you. You're making my Christmas very merry.

So!
UGG Australia and
Koolaburra. When talking about "The Real Thing" in terms of sheepskin boots, a boot from one of these two companies is what people are referring to. There's a lot of legal history and bad blood between these two companies, but I couldn't find an unbiased source for information on the dispute, so I'll be leaving the politics out and focusing solely on the shoes.
This brings us to the big defining question: What's the difference? Koolaburra's are more expensive. UGG's are in higher demand. Why are both of them so much more expensive than the others? We will start with what is the same.
- -Both originated in Australia, and found success in the U.S. (specifically California) prompting them to move their headquarters to Santa Barbara County in California.
- - Both UGG and Koolaburra use twin (or double) face sheepskin. This means the bond between the sheepskin and the fleece in your boot is stronger because the fleece was never disconnected from the sheepskin.
- - Both companies only use the highest quality of sheepskin in the construction of their boots.
The differences are a little harder to lay down. We'll start with the elephant in the room:
All Koolaburra boots are made in Australia. UGG boots are made in New Zealand and China, depending on which style you're purchasing. For some people the country of origin is important. For some people it isn't. If you're looking for a strictly Australian sheepskin boot, Koolaburra is going to be your answer. If you're not comfortable with a Chinese guy making your Australian boot, but you're o.k. with a Kiwi overseeing its creation, you'll be fine if you stick to the "Ultra" product line of UGG. They're all made in the New Zealand factories. UGG's classic line is manufactured in China, which you will see if you check the "Made In" label. If you don't care what nationality slaved over your boots as long as they get under your tree by Christmas, you can view the next batch of information objectively to help you make your decision.
Lets compare apples to apples:
Koolaburra Classics vs. UGG Classics.
The description for Koolaburra in these comparisons is going to be largely repetitive, but hey.. don't fix what isn't broken. Koolaburra classics are, as mentioned, all double faced sheepskin. UGG Classics also use twin-faced sheepskin, but the inside is then cemented to a cow leather outside to make it more durable. What you wind up with when comparing them side by side is a soft supple boot inside and out (Koolaburra) and a boot that is soft inside, but a little more rigid and durable on the outside (UGG). Depending on the lifestyle of your recipient, and level of care you can expect them to take with their boots, that might be an important factor in your decision.
Koolaburra Classics have a removable insole. UGG Classics do not. This can also be a factor worth paying attention to. With all fleece lined footwear, the fleece will start to compress as you wear them. If you bought them large or just right on the first wear, they will be too big after a few more. Changing out the insole to one with unsquished fluff can help if you didn't preplan for the compression.
Comparing costs, UGG Classics retail for
$130 for the shorts and
$160 for the talls this season. Koolaburra
shorts are going for $165 and the
talls are retailing at $190.
UGG Ultras vs. Koolaburra Excaliburs.
These would be the boots with the Australian/Tasman braiding up the back. (Some Koolaburra classics have the braiding up the back as well, so don't use the braid as an indicator with Koolaburra.)
- - Removable insole? Check.
- - All sheepskin throughout? Check.
- - All weather sole with reinforced toe and heel? Check.
- - Manufactured in a country with a 'downundah' accent? Check.
- - Retail price this holiday season? Short: $180 Tall: $200
As you can see, they are almost identical.
When it comes down to it, its a matter of style and personal preference. Koolaburra markets themselves as the little guy still holding strong to its roots. (Incidentally, so does Emu.) UGG markets itself with celebrity endorsement and a high fashion slant, the height of comfortable quality sheik. Fashion is one of the most reinforceable ways to display your individuality and personal identity. When trying to choose which label should be on the boots under your tree this year, look at the person you're buying for and what they value. And when it all comes down to it, if you're in a panic just remember: You can't go wrong with sheepskin boots. The details are just the icing on the cake.